Vicky Pryce, IWF UK Member and Economist
It was the economy that was most influential in determining the result of the midterms in the US. And it is the economy again that is behind the widespread protests across Europe. The cost-of-living increases from the war in Iran, particularly the sharp hike in petrol, diesel and fertiliser prices and in household energy costs, all added to the earlier impact on prices of Trump’s tariffs. So forgive me for stealing such an overused title for my short update note, though I have to confess that it has already served as the main part on the cover of my 2015 book, whose overall title was: ‘It’s The Economy, Stupid: Economics for Voters’.
Across the world, countries have struggled with the price shock, and many have stepped in to relieve some of the pressures with subsidies and tax cuts. This has inevitably led to further deterioration in public finances, which has added to the pressures from the Covid period. As a result, we now have what looks like seriously punitive government borrowing costs. With central bank interest rates on the rise too, as higher inflation has re-emerged due to the Iran war, households are inevitably suffering as well. In the UK, which already has one of the highest electricity costs for businesses and households in the G7, real living standards are expected to rise at their slowest pace in decades for the rest of this parliament. On that basis, the Office for Budget Responsibility downgraded its GDP forecast for next year to just 1%.
Not everyone shares this pessimism. The Bank of England has revised its forecast up for this year to 1.6%. On the face of it, the world has been reasonably resilient during the tariff wars and the current and continuing Iran conflict. Maybe the private sector has learned to cope with crises, which seem to come thick and fast. Maybe governments are also better able to respond, despite having to pay a higher price to the capital markets to finance their interventions? Indeed, the UK economy posted growth of 0.7% in the summer, the highest quarterly performance for two years, and beat most expectations.
The Budget of October 28 has been pretty neutral fiscally while parking major decisions until later. That includes defence spending and what it will require to get to 3% of GDP by 2030; changes to welfare, including the treatment of young people not in education, employment or training, the so-called NEETs; greater regional devolution; and the balance between pension upgrades and making more funds available for care for the old.
And, of course, Europe! Already the debate has restarted, with the battle lines redrawn, though similar arguments are being deployed again from the Brexit camp, while Europe enthusiasts point to the change in mood and to evidence collected in the 10 years since the vote. Again, economics will dominate. Those wanting closer links point to higher prices and a reduction in trade intensity since the UK’s exit from the EU, thus weakening productivity and growth, which the new UK PM is desperate for if he is to achieve his change agenda.
And for the voters, particularly if there is an early election? Look for facts, ignore the ideology.